Time.com

CNN.com

Search
Archive

HOME

U.S.

WORLD

BLOGS

BUSINESS &
TECH

HEALTH & SCIENCE

ENTERTAINMENT

PHOTOS

MAGAZINE

SPECIALS

A Clever Robot

Thursday, Jan. 18, 2007 By
DANIEL DENNETT

Article Tools

Print

Email

Reprints

Suppose Steve Pinker contracts a terrible progressive brain disease that
destroys his nervous system from the outside in--he starts going numb and then
deaf and blind and unable to control his muscles. But then neuroscience comes to
the rescue, replacing each portion of his nervous system as it disintegrates
with a suitably interfaced prosthesis made of silicon and wire.

Related

The New
Map Of The Brain

There are uncharted worlds inside your head, but science is drawing a
map

The
Mystery of Consciousness

You exist, right? Prove it. How 100 billion jabbering neurons create the
knowledge--or illusion--that you're here

How The
Brain Rewires Itself

Not only can the brain learn new tricks, but it can also change its structure
and function--even in old age

6
Lessons for Handling Stress

Take a deep breath. Now exhale slowly. You've just taken the first step
toward managing stress and avoiding burnout

Graphics

Five Paths to
Understanding the Brain

From gruesome ancient rituals to modern pharmacology, mankind had been trying
to discover what's really going on inside our heads. A short history

Video

Mysteries of Conciousness

Sarah Scantlin is a living medical miracle. An accident injured her brain so
severely she should have died, but 20 years later she has regained the ability
to speak
• Sarah Scantlin's Dad Speaks

Video

Exercise Your Brain

Dr. Sanjay Gupta tells us how we can keep our memory as we age and even
create new brain cells through mental and physical exercise
• Dr. Gupta Interviews Professor Arthur Kramer

More Videos
• Blind Learn To See With Tongue
• Helping The Blind To See
• A Look Inside A Baby's Brain
• How Your Brain Handles Stress
• Coping With Stress

Thanks to their success on the Easy Problems of consciousness, the scientists
meticulously provide artificial substitutes for all Steve's brain processes, so
to all outward appearances he is saved from terrible oblivion and death.
Moreover, he expresses his satisfaction with his restored feeling and sight and
continues speaking and writing with humor and eloquence, delighting his friends
and frustrating his critics.

But can we really be sure that he is expressing his satisfaction? His body
may be just "expressing" his satisfaction. Although it appears to all observers
that Steve believes he's alive and well, loves his family and is only slightly
distracted by the residual pain of his many surgeries, there seems to be a
possibility that the apparently animate body standing before us only "believes"
it is alive, only "loves" his family and is distracted not by real pain but by
"pain," the bogus kind that lacks the je ne sais quoi of genuine pain.

The trouble with this hypothesis is that it declares its own untestability at
the outset. There is nothing Steve could do or say under any circumstances that
would provide the slightest grounds for either dismissing or confirming the
reality of his experience. There could not be an objective test that
distinguished a clever robot from a really conscious person.

Now you have a choice: you can cling to the Hard Problem, or you can shake
your head in wonder and dismiss it. We've learned to do this before: it still
seems as if the sun goes around the earth, but we know better. It's not all that
hard, actually, now that we've made so much progress on the Easy Problems. Just
let go.

Dennett's most recent book is Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural
Phenomenon

Sphere
It!

|

|

|

Add RSS Feed

Related Links

Time
Travel in the Brain

What
Do Babies Know?

How We
Make Life-and-Death Decisions

The
Flavor Of Memories

Marketing
To Your Mind

The
Power of Hope

Who
Should Read Your Mind?

How To
Change A Personality

What
The Mouse Brain Tells Us

The
Gift Of Mimicry

Essay

The
Last Taboo

A Pipe
Organ

A
Story We Tell Ourselves

An
Unbridgeable Gulf

Top Stories

Can
KSM's Confession Be Believed?

Is a Top
School Forcing Out Low-Performing Students?

Meet
Angelina's Boy: Pax Thien Jolie

Most popular

1. 300 Sparks an Outcry in Iran

2. Meet
Angelina's Boy: Pax Thien Jolie

3. How The
Right Went Wrong

4. 7 Reasons
Why 300 is a Huge Hit

5. Is a Top
School Forcing Out Low-Performing Students?

6. Gonzales
Under Siege

7. A Way Out
of Iran's Nuclear Impasse?

8. Got Raw
Milk? Be Very Quiet

9. Q&A
with Frieda Hughes

10. A White
House Hand in the Firings?

Rollover
for TIME's Quotes of the Day

You will need to install or upgrade your Flash Player to be
able to view this Flash content. Also, Javascript must be turned on.

Grab It
to put Quotes of the Day on your blog or start page

Features

| Click arrows to view more features

More features

Nation
New Orleans' Guest Workers Fight Back

World

Coming Together on Palestinian Unity
The leaders of Hamas and Fatah seem sincere in their attempt
to form a unity government. But plenty of others, from George W. Bush to Ayman
al-Zawahiri, are complicating that effort

World
What Drew Halliburton to Dubai

World

A Way Out of Iran's Nuclear Impasse?
The country's U.N. ambassador is floating a promising idea,
reports Walter Isaacson: to turn over ownership of Iran's enrichment plants to
an international consortium

Entertainment
7 Reasons Why 300 is a Huge Hit

World

Iran Moves Out of the Isolation Booth
Last weekend's Baghdad talks brought the U.S. and Iran
together in the same room. Now Washington must realize that even its moderate
Arab allies want to engage Tehran

Q & A
Frieda Hughes on Being Sylvia Plath's Daughter

Health

Got Raw Milk? Be Very Quiet
The
market for unpasteurized milk is growing, but advocates face an array of state
and federal rules that make getting it a challenge

Mar.5 - Mar. 11
Cartoons of the Week

Nation

Reexamining "Don't Ask, Don't Tell"
Pace's statement that homosexuality is "immoral" won't
change the status quo, but the outcry is a clear sign that gays will
eventually be allowed to serve

Quick Links:

U.S.|World|Blogs|Business & Tech|Health & Science|Entertainment|Photos|Magazine|Specials|Archive

Get TIME RSS
Feeds|Get TIME on your Mobile
Device|TIME Podcasts

Services:

Subscribe
| Customer
Service|Help|Site Map|Contact Us|Privacy Policy|Terms of
Use|Media Kit|Reprints & Permissions|Opinion Leaders Panel

Editions:

TIME Domestic|TIME Europe|TIME Asia|TIME South Pacific|TIME For Kids

Time.com

Copyright © 2007 Time Inc. All rights
reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is
prohibited.